ESOP Pros and Cons

Click to Download Full Booklet

Information in this booklet has been developed for those owners of privately-held businesses who are interested in liquefying some portion of the equity which has accumulated in their companies. We have assumed that many of our readers may be interested in accomplishing this objective without sacrificing the identity of their companies, jeopardizing the jobs of valued employees or relinquishing control of the companies they own. An ESOP installation may provide the optimal solution for business owners hoping to achieve all of these goals. An ESOP (Employee Stock Ownership Plan) is a powerful and versatile business and financial tool which can help a business owner to accomplish the following:

The ESOP trust establishes the fair market value of the company’s privately-held stock and it also functions as the marketplace for that stock.
ESOPs assure flexibility by allowing an owner to liquefy whatever portion of his ownership he chooses. The owner does not have to sell the entire company in order to liquefy a portion of the accumulated equity in the company.
In situations where the company treasury does not have resources sufficient to liquefy the privately-held stock being conveyed to the ESOP, the ESOP is allowed to borrow the funds necessary to complete the transaction.
Moreover, the company owner does not have to relinquish control of his company. Regulations governing ESOP operations allow the owner to sit on the committee which oversees the ESOP. Indeed, the owner can be the sole voting committee member on the ESOP Committee if he so chooses.
In the case of a regular C corporation, if 30% or more of the company’s outstanding stock has been sold to the ESOP at the completion of the transaction, and the proceeds are reinvested in qualified replacement securities within twelve months from the date of sale, the selling shareholder can defer payment of the capital gains tax on the sale of privately-held stock to the ESOP.
In the case of S corporations, the ESOP creates a “tax shield” for part or all of the company’s earnings, depending upon the percentage of stock held by the ESOP. This shield results from a provision of the Code that exempts from taxation that portion of the corporation’s taxable income that is attributable to stock held by the ESOP. Thus, for example, in the case of a S corporation that is 100% owned by its ESOP, the company’s earnings will be entirely tax exempt.
The ESOP establishes an incentive-based retirement program for employees in the owner’s company, making them beneficial stock owners in the company where they work. This incentive can produce very positive benefits for the company’s bottom line profits.
National studies reveal that on average ESOP companies tend to be 8% to 11% more profitable than their non-ESOP counterparts. As a direct consequence of sharing ownership with his employees, the business owner reaps the added benefit of increased profits (and increased valuation) for himself and for his company.
A company can reduce its corporate income taxes and increase its cash flow and net worth by simply issuing treasury stock or newly issued stock to its ESOP.

The remainder of this booklet discusses and more fully explains these and other capabilities of this versatile and powerful business and financial tool.

Click here to download the entire ESOP Pros and Cons Booklet in pdf format

Share this article:

Learn why an ESOP is better for You,
your Business, and your Employees

Upcoming Web Seminar

Facing Headwinds, Building Ownership:

How ESOPs Help Businesses Navigate Rising Costs, Market Uncertainty & Succession Planning.

Free 90-Minute Webinar for Business Owners, CFOs & Advisors

📉 The Economic Reality

Inflation. Tariffs. Tight labor markets. Cost of capital on the rise.

2025 is shaping up to be a year where strategic moves—not reactive cuts—will define the companies that come out stronger. If you’re a private company leader facing rising costs and succession pressures, now is the time to consider the unique benefits of an Employee Stock Ownership Plan (ESOP).

🚀 What You’ll Learn

✅ ESOP 101: How it works, who qualifies, and why it’s more relevant than ever

✅ Countering Margin Pressure: Offset cost increases from tariffs and wages using ESOP tax incentives

✅ Tax Strategies for Owners & Companies: Capital gains deferral, corporate income tax reduction, and more

✅ Talent Retention: Keep your best employees with meaningful ownership—not just raises

✅ Valuation & Financing: Understand the 2025 deal landscape and flexible funding models

📌 Who Should Attend

This session is ideal for:

- Business Owners planning an exit or recap
- CFOs evaluating corporate tax or capital strategy
- Succession Planners seeking values-aligned ownership transitions
- HR & ESOP Committee Members aiming to understand the full value of employee ownership

💬 Hear From Past Attendees

“I came in skeptical. I left with a clear understanding of how ESOPs could be our best path forward—even in an uncertain economy.”

— Mark T., CFO, Manufacturing Company

"This webinar helped clarify both the exit plan and how we can support employees at the same time."

— Susan D., Founder & CEO, B2B Services Firm

🎯 Why 2025 is the Time for ESOPs

ESOPs can create a rare win-win:

- Liquidity for founders without third-party control
- Tax savings that protect cash and buffer costs
- Employee ownership that attracts, retains, and motivates talent
- In today’s economic climate, that edge is no longer optional—it’s essential.